Mar
28
2014

Sekret by Lindsay Smith

Title: Sekret
Series: Sekret #1
Author: Lindsay Smith
Publisher: Roaring Book Press
Release Date: April 1, 2014
Pages: 341
Source: ALA Midwinter

Summary from Goodreads:
An empty mind is a safe mind.

Yulia's father always taught her to hide her thoughts and control her emotions to survive the harsh realities of Soviet Russia. But when she's captured by the KGB and forced to work as a psychic spy with a mission to undermine the U.S. space program, she's thrust into a world of suspicion, deceit, and horrifying power. Yulia quickly realizes she can trust no one--not her KGB superiors or the other operatives vying for her attention--and must rely on her own wits and skills to survive in this world where no SEKRET can stay hidden for long.


Review

*Long exacerbated sigh* I have so many problems with this book I don't even know where to begin...

Let's start with the synopsis. "Yulia's father always taught her to hide her thoughts and control her emotions to survive the harsh realities of Soviet Russia." This statement is bullshit. On many accounts. But the one glaringly obvious from the beginning is that Yulia can't hide her thoughts or control her emotions. But I wish she could because all she could think about were boys and escaping and her emotions were all over the damn place. One minute she is super angry and defiant. The next she is too tired to feel anything. Another and she's accepting and willing to try. There was no consistency, but worse yet, there was no cause and effect. Her emotions were quite random and fleeting. I guess I have to mention that she did learn to shield her thoughts from others. How you ask? Khrushchev told her to play a song in her head  (and think underneath that music) and BAM instant shield. Now let's all try to play a song in our head and think at the same time...  And at one point she even had two layers of thoughts and music - like thoughts - ballad- thoughts - another ballad. What the-?

"But when she's captured by the KGB and forced to work as a psychic spy with a mission to undermine the U.S. space program, she's thrust into a world of suspicion, deceit, and horrifying power." Horrifying power, ok, I agree with that. I guess. Although I wouldn't say I felt horrified. But regarding her mission, WHAT mission? This book was all talk and no action. I remember pausing at page 170 and asking myself what the hell I had been reading cause sure as shit nothing noteworthy had happened yet. The mission took such a back seat to Yulia's seemingly random-ass back and forth thoughts and feelings that I didn't even know what the heck the mission was or what they were doing for it for the majority of the book. At page 229 I paused again and thought again that I didn't know what the heck they were doing. The few trips they had taken didn't really connect to a bigger purpose.  There was no direction and certainly not enough focus on the actual plot until the very end (at best). 

"Yulia quickly realizes she can trust no one--not her KGB superiors or the other operatives vying for her attention--and must rely on her own wits and skills to survive in this world where no SEKRET can stay hidden for long."  What whit and skills? I mean, really. 

And I have to mention the boy situation although I'd rather think about ANYTHING but. Despite Yulia thinking about boys for like 72% of this book ( I'd say 25% was spent thinking or attempting some stupid escape plan that was destined to fail and 3% was the actual plot) I can't really say there was a romance or love triangle. It was more like Yulia would seriously consider any boy in her line of vision. Ok, I guess to be fair there was only two. But it felt like 'Oh hey, there's Segei', 'I like Sergei' or 'Oh hey, look at Valentin playing the piano.' I like Valentin'. And naturally when she liked one, she didn't like the other. Ok, so maybe she was always building towards one but really the whole boy situation was painful, overdone and in no way believable or enjoyable.

What else... Oh, if you are hoping to watch her learn about her power and master it. Don't hold your breath. And If you want to read an intriguing Historical Fiction set in Russia with a Paranormal spy twist. Look elsewhere. 

And the writing was weird and inconsistent (I am sensing a pattern of inconsistency here). At times I was reminded of Tehereh Mafi's writing  - kind of choppy, maybe a little poetic. Except it really didn't work here.

Alright, I think I will stop there. I will say that I have seen others enjoy this book, and I have seen others who share some of my sentiments. I could be extra critical because of how disappointed I was in this book that had so much potential. But it is rare for me to be so harsh. So I'd recommend that you approach this one with caution. 

divider

Comments (17)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
I was SO excited for this book when I first read the blurb, so of course I requested the ARC on NG when it came up but got denied. Then I started seeing the not so great reviews start coming in, but this one really zinches it. I won't be bothering with it anymore. I was expecting this: "Historical Fiction set in Russia with a Paranormal spy twist" and I guess it won't be delivering that :(

Great review, Nicole!
My recent post Upcoming New Releases - Week of March 31st
1 reply · active 574 weeks ago
I was really excited too and that definitely played a part in why I felt so disappointed in the end. Maybe now that your expectations are lowered you will be able to enjoy it more. But with all of the good books out there, I am not sure this one is really worth the time =/
GAHH I was so excited to snag this one from ALA but GAHHH. Maybe I'll just go in with low expectations!
1 reply · active 574 weeks ago
Low expectations would definitely help. And patience hah. I have seen some people love it - reviews tend to be on the two extremes. So idk. I hope for your sake you fall into the "love it" category!
I DNFed this one, and I'm glad I did. Seems like it definitively wouldn't have gotten better for me, which is such a shame. I loooove reading about the Soviet Union, but the inconsistencies in the book were driving me crazy. I mean, supposedly she had to touch people to read their thoughts, but then she'd randomly read people from across the room! Anyway, that bit about Yulia realizing she can't trust anyone? I quit when she really did have that revelation, because she lives in the freaking Soviet Union and is being controlled by the KGB. Of COURSE you can't trust anyone. Your parents told you you couldn't trust anyone. Why is this a shock?
1 reply · active 574 weeks ago
Hah I read your DNF thoughts and agree 100% with how you were feeling. This book was frustrating beyond belief.
Oh boo. I was looking forward to this one, but the heroine doesn't seem all that likeable. It's too bad because I am a fan of KGB stories.
1 reply · active 574 weeks ago
There wasn't even enough focus on Soviet Russia, the KGB, or any of the country's history for me to feel comfortable recommending this book to you for that reason alone. And it was so frustrating. I can't see it being worth your time, but that's just my opinion
Pam@YA Escape's avatar

Pam@YA Escape · 574 weeks ago

Ok, tell us what you really think. :) That's so disappointing, the synopsis made this book sound so good. But reviews are sort of all over the place with this one, so I'm not sure about it. Maybe if I have absolutely nothing else to read...not sure when that's going to happen. If I can get it as a library book, maybe I'll try it and keep my expectations really low, but otherwise, I think I'll pass.
My recent post Discussion Question: Thoughts About Star Ratings?
1 reply · active 574 weeks ago
I know I was a little harsh. It happens on occasion when I get really frustrated. I was just so excited, and I saw some positive reviews which made me all the more hopeful and then I felt like I was reading another book because I just didn't see the 5 star potential in it at all. And I think that's why my opinion shifted to the extremely negative. But that obviously won't happen for everyone. It can't hurt to try it if you're curious. There is always DNFing, right?
I've decided that I LOVE snarky Nicole reviews! Not only did this review make me want to avoid reading this book, because I know that the things that drove you crazy would do the same for me, it also made me laugh! It's a bummer that the writing was so off and didn't work. It's such a promising idea, but I guess books can't work for everyone. Great review!
My recent post [Review: Salvage by Alexandra Duncan]
1 reply · active 574 weeks ago
Hah I am glad you enjoyed my snark ;) And yeah I can't really see you liking this one all that much so it's probably a good idea to pass.
Eep, I can tell you're really angry at the book when you wrote this Nicole and frankly, I would be angry too.
I don't like it when things like this happens - when the character isn't supposed to feel any emotions, yet they do nothing but ACT on their emotions.
And that thought music thing? I've seen that done before in another book, but not in THAT weird way.
A character that fickle when it comes to guys? No thank you.
Great review Nicole! (:
My recent post Stacking the Shelves [73]
1 reply · active 574 weeks ago
Maybe just a liiiiiiitle bit frustrated hah. But for good reason! Sadly, it was like a snowball effect, I started getting more and more frustrated as I read that by the time I finished I think steam was coming out of my ears. *sigh*
Yup, I'm 100% not reading this book after reading your review. If you only gave it one star then I know you really didn't like it. I trust your opinion and I want to read way too many books that sound good so why waste my time on a dud? Plus, I'm not a fan of a synopsis that lies. :(
My recent post Library Loot #17
2 replies · active 573 weeks ago
Yeah, even if you wind up liking this more than me, the most I could see you giving this is 3 stars, maybe. Probably best to just skip.
I'm def skipping. Thanks again for reviewing this so I don't waste my precious reading time. :)
My recent post Review: Just Destiny by: Theresa Rizzo

Post a new comment

Comments by

Copyright © 2014 The Quiet Concert
Template and Design by New Chapter Designs